Reservation
+1 619-464-6012
Visit Us
6195 Lake Murray Blvd, La Mesa, CA 91942, United States
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ We usually have a pizza or their meat lasagna. Last night we ordered the 3/4kb hamburger, fries and onion rings. We will be ordering those from here for now on. Price, product, packaging and delivery ”
“ Since moving back to the west coast after living in Brooklyn for the last half decade, this has been my go-to pizza spot. Artichoke chicken is awesome, I once tried to get adventurous with the Mexican pizza option but the result did not look like the picture online and was not the best choice I’ve had so far. Hasn’t stopped me from working my way through the rest of the pizza options on the menu to find a new favorite I the future though. ”
“ Best food I’ve ever had, go there immediately! ”
“ When we first moved to La Mesa we tried their New York pizza and it was delicious. We were tired from moving and were so delighted with how yummy their pizza and salads were. Everyone there is so nice and you can tell they just want to make good pizza. Fast forward a year and I ordered from them online. I got there about 30 mins after I order and when I got there and my pizza was still waiting to be made, they happily bumped up my order because I was already there. They are great. We love supporting local businesses and will always order from them when we want pizza. ”
“ Wow. Sooo good. All the food we got exceeded our expectations. We did a half and half pizza, zucchini sticks and meat ravioli. We can't wait to go back soon to try several of their other intriguing options. People were awesome too. The lady at the register was friendly and helped us find a great option. Please head over there and try their food. You won't be disappointed. ”
“ Best place to order pizza take out. The price is very affordable, the quality is great, fresh, and tastes very good. The thin crust is really thin. They make exactly as you order as quickly as possible. The location is very convenient, there is always a parking spot available and the employees are decent and efficient. Anything else you're looking for? Lol ”
“ My son, and I loved this place! Great service, and even better food. I especially loved that the pizza dough is fresh, and hand tossed. We’ve been lagging to try their food, but I’m glad we finally did, and will definitely be back! ”
“ First try and didn’t disappoint, been awhile not having NY style pizza so this Philly Steak Pizza has served its purpose, satisfying hungry teenagers in my house ”
Menu
Carrot Cake
US$7.99Pesto Sauce (Homemade)
US$3.00Ranch (Homemade)
US$2.50Thousand Islands
US$2.50Italian
US$2.50
About
New York New York Pizza & Pasta
Welcome to New York New York Pizza & Pasta, a vibrant culinary gem nestled in La Mesa, California. Located at 6195 Lake Murray Blvd, this eatery brings a slice of authentic New York flavor to the West Coast. With a stellar reputation, bolstered by rave reviews from satisfied patrons, it's no wonder this spot is a local favorite.
One of the highlights of New York New York Pizza & Pasta is their commitment to quality. Customers like Kevin Powell rave about the deliciousness of their pizza and the standout meat lasagna. His experience with the 3/4kb hamburger, which comes paired with crispy fries and onion rings, showcases the diverse menu that caters to both pizza lovers and those craving hearty American classics.
Forrest Bashaw, a former Brooklynite, found his go-to pizza spot here after moving back to the West Coast. The restaurant's artichoke chicken pizza has become a personal favorite, establishing itself as a must-try. While experimenting with the Mexican pizza didn't yield the best results for him, it just confirms how varied their menu is, encouraging customers to explore and discover their unique tastes.
Continuously fueled by customer satisfaction, Rachael Plambek shares her delightful experience as a newcomer to La Mesa. After a long day of moving, she and her family were thrilled to savor delicious New York pizza and fresh salads. Rachael lauds the friendly service, highlighting how the staff so eagerly bumped up her order when she arrived early, reinforcing their commitment to exceptional customer care.
Kelly Hernandez echoes this enthusiasm, calling her meal “sooo good” and noting that the half-and-half pizza, zucchini sticks, and meat ravioli exceeded their expectations. The friendly staff left a lasting impression, enhancing the overall dining experience with helpful recommendations and genuine hospitality.
At New York New York Pizza & Pasta, every bite is crafted with care, making it a must-visit not only for pizza lovers but for anyone seeking comfort food that warms the heart. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this eatery promises flavors that linger long after the last slice is gone. Come support a wonderful local business and indulge in pizzas that taste just like they came from the Big Apple itself!
Book a table